Don't get me wrong, 'Val' is captivating and compelling viewing. Kilmer was, after all, one of Hollywood's top-dog actors of the late '80s, early '90s-and he basically filmed his entire life, which creates interest, authenticity and nostalgia. However, despite the film's main theme being about the ability of acting to create the illusion of truth, this documentary manages to steer clear of any honesty or meaningful revelations about its main character.
The central question for anyone remotely aware of Kilmer is likely, 'What happened to that guy?' Largely because he was one of those actors who went from 0 to 100 overnight, from 'Top Secret' to 'Top Gun', from nobody to Jim Morrison. Then he disappeared just as fast.
Through home videos and a one-man film crew-Kilmer himself, seemingly capturing every waking moment of his own life-we get to know this character's major plot points, yet oddly never really get close to the answers to our questions.
The film seems to follow basically a chronological timeline of Kilmer's childhood, entry into acting and major film career, jumping out occasionally into his life today, dealing with a difficult medical condition. Again, it's compelling viewing. There's a brutal honesty and bravery involved in Kilmer allowing the world an uncomfortable glimpse into his post-surgery personal life.
However, you begin to notice some glaring omissions, most notably a missing 20 years when his career slid off a cliff, begging the questions: What happened to his career? How did he go from A-list to C-list? What happened to his marriage?
Despite the phenomenal home-shot footage and well-curated soundtrack, after a while, you begin to suspect that the actor might have left his most convincing and honest material on the cutting room floor, that perhaps not every tragedy that befell him was someone else's fault, and that the intent of the film was not in fact to document the truth, but to purposely obfuscate it.
It's totally understandable that someone who has gone through tough times, made some mistakes and perhaps behaved less than admirably would want to gloss over those moments and flaws. However, there is no hero's journey without recognition and growth. So the end result is less of a compelling, insightful life story and more of a nostalgic memoir.