I have been a huge fan of the original staged musical and have watched it twice. I have also watched the documentary that inspired this musical, its lovely to see how close it works to the original story whilst also sewing in refreshing and special themes and character.
I had a lot of anticipation for this movie and this admittedly built up a lot of anxiety - could they do the stage show justice?
First hearing they removed some of the original songs from the musical, my favourites too, I was worried. But, watching the film, completely open minded I can truly say it has definitely done the musical justice.
You can't go into this film expecting it to be an exact replica of the stage show. That's what the live stage filming in 2018 was for, this was broadcast in cinemas and hopefuly will be released on streaming / DVD / Blu Ray too (which was also amazing).
It's understandable that things had to change for the movie, one difference I noticed was Jamie New himself, the character on screen felt slightly toned down compared to the character on stage. I feel this was due to Jamie's presence on stage needing to be more exaggerated, and such portrayal of Jamie by Jon McCrea (one of my favourites) captures so much cheek, confidence, and stage presence. Newcomer Max Harwood brings his unique and 'more close to the real life' Jamie on screen; Embodying the real life Jamie Campbell (FiFi la True) and he has done a superb job. Love how you see more confidence in Jamie progress throughout the movie, whilst also having it all along. Interesting to see the identity challenges too of when to bring Miss 'Me me me' out: at school, just at the club, how much of her is Jamie etc...
When I say more realistic and less exaggerated, I don't mean this as a critique. In fact most stage shows / musicals, when adapted to the big screen face a significant challenge of how to best catch the fire behind the character without it coming across too animated. And this movie finds the perfect balance by blending the setting of Sheffield, school, and Jamie's home, with the fabulously choreographed performances that provide a burst of colour, flashbacks and escape. This balance works so well with lifting the music to the level it needs to be, whilst also capturing the simple yet impactful meaning behind its story.
Great New touches make such a difference too with character development, something a movie adaptation really gives the opportunity to exercise. Such as a few seconds clip of Dean Paxton in his home with a drunken father lay in the background, and Drag mother Loco Channel offering a heartfelt visit to some of the most challenging times in the 80/ 90s through his song 'this was me' . A couple examples here of powerful and meaningful touches to the film.
All the above offers fans the Jamie New they have learnt to love whilst giving them more & inviting newcomers to a joyous and welcoming musical with an uplifting message.
Reason I gave 9 out of 10, to deserve the last star I do believe an extra burst of energy and emotion in some of the key characters could have helped further keep the pace and atmosphere. Nevertheless, superb!
P. S. Keep your eyes out for some lovely Easter eggs, the original Jamie (in Drag) opening the door for Max Harwood into legs eleven & Jamie's mother as the shop keeper.