Antonio Bido's previous foray into the Giallo sub genre, The Cat's Victims, was a rather messy and highly derivative affair, so I'm pleased to report that he's improved greatly for this follow-up. Typically for Giallo, The Blood-Stained Shadow features a convoluted plot, and unfortunately Bido's plot pacing can be a little off at times, as the film is painfully slow at some points, and then whimsically clever at others. Luckily, the director uses the atmosphere from the Venetian Island upon which the film is set well, and even during the 'down time', there is enough about the film to keep it ticking over in a pleasant manner. The plot starts with a shot of a dead body; a young girl whose murderer was never discovered. We pick up the plot some time later when a young man has returned to his home, which also happens to be the place where his brother, the local priest, lives. After having being told by his brother of all the immoral people in the town, a group which includes gamblers, perverts and con artists, the dead bodies begin to pile up. Is there a connection with the murder years earlier?
The Cat's Victims was clearly very derivative of the great Dario Argento, and this film is too. The film isn't as well put together as the likes of Deep Red and Tenebrae, but Bido does a good job of imitating the superior director. The murder scenes are very well orchestrated and really quite nasty also; as we've got a man getting an axe through the heart, a woman having her head forced into a fire and other such gory highlights. The score by Stelvio Cipriani is a particular highlight, as the heavy tones suit the movie excellently and provide it with one of its strongest elements. Naturally with this kind of plot, it can be a little difficult to follow at times as random events occur at regular intervals; but Bido makes good of it by the end, as everything comes together in a way that makes sense and manages a genuine surprise for the audience. Overall, while The Blood-Stained Shadow isn't one of the heavyweight 'must see' films of the Giallo cycle, it has enough strongpoint's to ensure that it will be a point of interest for Giallo fans, and while the director has borrowed, perhaps even a little too much, seeing all the common Giallo elements in a film together is a treat. Recommended!