source: They

We have a young person ready for transition, their sister facing difficult career choice, and her boyfriend being a migrant doctor seeking to get a green card by getting married. The film could be very interesting but lack focus of any of the issues faced by these characters, and wasted almost a third of the time in a totally pointless Iranian party.

Nice camerawork but lot's of mumbling throughout this film. The main character mumbles and it's distracting and alienating.

The cinematography and direction are gorgeous, and "They" is a constant visual feast. The premise is extremely interesting, and the movie deals with it with good taste and subtelty. So it is a bit frustrating that the narrative tends to scatter. With a better focus in the writing, "They" could have become a classic.

This is a strange film that purports to be about gender identity but didn't seem to be about gender at all. The lead character J happens to be non-binary but the film is mostly about all kinds of other experiences in J's family, particularly about J's sister, an artist, getting married to a man from Iran, who is having issues with his own family. J's medical transition seemed to be a secondary plot and J seemed to be more concerned about not wanting to grow up at all rather than being concerned with gender. I wonder whether the director thought the gender issue was just a trendy way to pitch the film. I also wonder whether the director was trying to show that gender is the least important thing to worry about in life. This is the kind of film that would make me want to attend a question and answer session with the director.

This is a movie where not many people have seen it but it's one of those ideas that ideally should work out. This is the first movie that I'm aware of with a non-binary lead character. I stumbled on this little fact a while ago and thought that it's worth taking a look at on that alone. So I found a copy and watched it and if you're expecting anything amazing then I have disappointing news, I then looked on here and didn't think the other haters had the right perspective so I finally decided to write a review on it. The set-up is that J is a teen who identifies as non-binary. They've been on puberty blockers for years and unsure of which puberty is right for them. Unfortunately their doctor says that now is the time to get J off and has the whole weekend or so to decide whether to grow up as more male or female, while feeling disconnected from their older sister and her boyfriend. In terms of what I didn't like, then the directing is awful. The other haters criticised the acting (my thoughts on that later) but faces being cut off in shots so you only see half of someones face for no artistic reason, stuff in the foreground obscuring actors faces, showing a conversation either through a single character is all we see for most of a three person conversation or have the oly thing we see being what they browse on their computer (TWICE!) and a shot where you only see a finger tapping on a car door to convey that J was in there. I'm sure there's other stuff in here but it's distracting how much it either feels like there's no effort into the shots or they tried too hard to be avant-garde and make their mark, but failed. There's also another thing, it's about how they handle the topic of the movie. For a movie about being non-binary you'd expect some persecution, some idiot being wrong about it in a way that denies their existence. Gone (or I should say off-screen in a visual medium, we only hear second hand from J themselves)! J coming out is gone! What the choice the whole movie hinges around as is gone. The last thing is that for 20 minutes in this 80 minute movie we focus entirely on Iranian-American people and the struggles they go through. Look, this is fascinating stuff and in another movie I wouldn't have minded but the problem is that for the entire time I was thinking "Hey, doesn't J have to contemplate their decision?" It feels like an entirely different film. I really wanted to like this so I'll go through what I actually liked about this movie. I did say some harsh things about the directing earlier (I backed it up but my point is you can make your own judgement on what I had to say to back it up) but one thing that is captured is the disconnection between J and the stuff around them that doesn't involve this decision. We know that they like poetry and there's one they keep repeating that's meant to convey their loss of youth and the scariness going forward and whether what they decide is a mistake. All of that is done well and Rhys Fehrenbacher does pull the performance off. Him being a trans boy mid-transition playing this role also makes it a lot more believable. In short, the amount of potential I saw in this movie was enormous. I understand how representation matters in fiction (namely if they aren't represented then long story short, stuff like being non-binary is an alien concept to some and may not lead to as widespread acceptance) and to see it end up like this is really disheartening. I really wanted to like this. Trust me in saying that, and I did find stuff in it to like. It's inescapably not very good. I'm really, really sorry. Check it out if you're curious but if not - I wouldn't bother to be honest.

I have no idea in what realm this would be considered a "movie." While the young actor who plays "J" has a beautiful, haunted face and, with direction, might be someone fantastic in the future, and while the director captures beautiful scenes of nature, there is no story here. A teen, J, is apparently left at home while his/her ("their") parents have gone to Poland on the day that his older sister and her Iranian boyfriend have come back to keep an eye on J. J is questioning his/her sexuality and is apparently taking some medications which, at some point, he/she will have to decide whether to continue to take. In the midst of this story are bizarre, pointless scenes about the lives of older sister and boyfriend. The other actors in this film are flat and emotionless and are just saying lines they were given to recite. Nothing happens. Suddenly, about mid-way through we find ourselves at the home of the Iranian boyfriend's aunt who is throwing a party. There is some veiled concern about how to refer to the sister's "sibling." Despite the beautify of Rhys Fehrenbacher ("J"), who has a lot of drama and pain and beauty in his/her eyes, I cannot see or understand the point of this "film." I endured the first 30 minutes, which moved at a snail's pace, and then I kept fast-forwarding 10 seconds and could not get to the end fast enough. The poster is stunning and hints at a beautiful film which does not ever occur. I'm saddened as I really wanted to appreciate/acknowledge/understand/learn and grow from this experience. None of those were possible as the film doesn't offer enough for anyone to grasp on to.

This film is an intimate portrait of a person - J or the eponymous "they" - who simply cannot decide if they want to become a man or a woman. They wish they could be a child forever. This indecision is a theme that director Anahita Ghazvinizadeh masterfully weaves into the entire story. Influenced by Robert Bresson's concept of ellipsis and fragmentation, the film is subtle but visually beautiful, just like the main character J, excellently played by Rhys Fehrenbacher. One learns about gender nonconformity and comes to the realization that gender perhaps really doesn't matter in the end as long as you have people who support you.

Beautifully shot, gorgeous cinematography. Well acted. A very important and sensitive tale.

Terrible acting, too much focus on irrelevant matters, no specific story going on. Videography was good though and The "J" actress was beautiful.